Go Ahead. Dare me.

Toward the end of seminary, my New Testament professor dared us to use non-canonical texts in worship and study. He encouraged us to engage faithful people in authentic study of these words that were not included in the traditional canon. I respond really well to dares. It’s one of the things that I like about Christianity. I like the challenge. I like that Jesus has the gumption to say the poor will always be with us. Oh yeah? Well, we’ll see about that Jesus. We will just have to see about that. In the words of Barney Stinson: challenge accepted. Like I said, I respond really well to dares.

I took my seminary professor’s challenge to heart.

When National Geographic got everyone’s attention with their talk of the Gospel of Judas, I used the text in a sermon. Somehow, earlier this winter, I got into a conversation with our Wednesday morning Bible study about these mysterious texts outside the canon. Since I first studied them in college, these texts have challenged my identity as a Christian so perhaps it is not surprising that I talk about them, but I never would have expected this small group to want to study these texts together. Lo and behold, we are. I chose three texts for us to study together in the Easter Season. Of course, in the spirit of my seminary professor’s dare, I want to expand the conversation. So, this Sunday, I’ll preach the good news from the Gospel of Peter.

As I’m writing my sermon, I find myself asking big questions about what makes something sacred. Several years ago, when I attended the very first Young Clergy Women Conference at the College of Preachers, I preached a sermon to my small working group that used a piece of poetry with a lesson from the Bible. A woman who has since become a friend scolded me, saying, “You shouldn’t be exegeting that poem. The emphasis should be on the Bible.”

I find that phrase bouncing around in my head again as I write this sermon. I am preaching a text that is not in the canon. Our church fathers and mothers condemned this text as a heresy, but does that mean that these words shared by a community in Syria don’t have something to teach us about being faithful Christians? Isn’t all of life holy? Isn’t there holiness outside of the words that generations after generations have held to be sacred? Don’t we believe (at least in the United Church of Christ) that God is still speaking? Doesn’t that mean that God could be bigger than 66 books?

I honestly don’t know, but I’m up for the challenge.

8 thoughts on “Go Ahead. Dare me.

  1. I always want to know *why* a preacher is bringing something in from outside the community's tradition. I've seen non-canonical gospels brought in without any reason given for why they were used, and it can be divisive and confusing. There's a mystique surrounding these non-canonical texts, sometimes, that congregations are expected to share but often don't, and it can make the preacher/teacher seem very out of touch with the larger community if he/she doesn't get beyond the mystique to what's really valuable about the text.


  2. @outoftheearth, I pray that I can get beyond the mystique of any text. Sometimes I find it difficult to not simply stand in awe of the power of the story — whether or not those words are from the canon. I hope that every story we share in worship points toward that mystery of God.


  3. As someone who both loves the canonical texts and who has a love for all of the ways in which God speaks to us, this is right where I'm at.
    Reading (and re-reading) your post, I'm left with the advice I offered a seminary classmate who was worried about preaching on the OT reading (or some such), “We must always preach the Gospel, not on the Gospel.”
    Now I'll go back to my in the lectionary sermon. But I am having some fun with medieval history. 🙂


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: